The right refinance depends on what you want the new loan to do. Most homeowners end up comparing four options: a rate-and-term refinance, a cash-out refinance, an FHA Streamline, or a VA Interest Rate Reduction Refinance Loan (IRRRL).
Some goals don't need a new mortgage at all. A recast, PMI cancellation, or a home equity loan can cost less than refinancing.
Start with your goal, then check whether the savings will cover the closing costs. That order keeps you from choosing a loan just because its rate looks good.
Match the option to your goal
| Your goal | Option to compare first | Main trade-off |
|---|
| Lower your rate or monthly payment | Rate-and-term refinance | Closing costs must be recovered before you sell or refinance again |
| Pay the loan off sooner | Refinance to a shorter term, such as 15 or 20 years | Higher monthly payment |
| Take cash out of your equity | Cash-out refinance | The new rate applies to the whole balance, not just the cash |
| Lower the rate on an FHA loan | FHA Streamline Refinance | Must provide a net tangible benefit; you still pay FHA mortgage insurance |
| Lower the rate on a VA loan | VA IRRRL | Rate must drop at least 0.5 point (fixed to fixed); costs recouped within 36 months |
| Lower your payment and keep your rate | Mortgage recast | Requires a lump-sum principal payment; the rate doesn't change |
| Stop paying PMI | PMI cancellation on your current loan | Depends on your loan-to-value and payment history |
| Borrow without replacing a low first-mortgage rate | Home equity loan or line of credit | A second payment, usually at a higher rate |
Rate-and-term refinance
A rate-and-term refinance replaces your mortgage with a new loan for about the same balance, at a different rate, term, or both. It's the usual choice when market rates are below your current rate, or when you want to switch from an adjustable rate to a fixed rate.
The deciding number is your break-even point: closing costs divided by monthly savings. If you expect to sell or refinance again before that point, the refinance loses money even with a lower rate. The refinance calculator shows the break-even month and the total cost over the time you expect to keep the loan.
Waiting periods differ by loan type. See rate-and-term refinance seasoning rules by loan type before applying.
Shorter-term refinance
Moving from a 30-year to a 15- or 20-year loan usually gets a lower rate and much less total interest, but a higher monthly payment. Some lenders also offer terms between the standard lengths. Compare the required payment with what you could pay voluntarily on your current loan: extra principal payments shorten a loan without closing costs, though they don't lower the rate.
Cash-out refinance
A cash-out refinance replaces your mortgage with a larger loan and pays you the difference. For a conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae, the existing first mortgage generally must be at least 12 months old. Fannie Mae's eligibility matrix caps a one-unit primary home at 80% loan-to-value. Lenders can set stricter limits.
Because the new rate applies to the entire balance, a cash-out refinance can cost more than it appears when your current rate is low. See how much cash you can take out and compare it with a home equity loan.
FHA Streamline Refinance
If you have an FHA loan, an FHA Streamline Refinance can lower your rate with less documentation than a standard refinance. The new loan must provide a net tangible benefit, such as a lower combined rate including mortgage insurance. Ask the lender whether an appraisal is required for your situation. If you're within three years of your last FHA loan, you may qualify for a partial upfront MIP refund.
VA IRRRL
A VA Interest Rate Reduction Refinance Loan refinances an existing VA loan into a new VA loan at a lower rate. Not every rate drop qualifies. Under 38 U.S.C. § 3709, a fixed-rate loan refinanced into another fixed rate must get a rate at least 0.5 percentage point lower. Moving from a fixed rate to an adjustable rate requires a drop of at least 2 percentage points. The lender must also show that fees and closing costs are recouped through lower payments within 36 months. The loan being refinanced must also meet seasoning rules: six monthly payments and at least 210 days since the first payment due date. See which VA IRRRL closing costs you can roll into the loan.
Options that don't require a new mortgage
Recast: you pay a lump sum toward principal and the servicer re-amortizes the remaining balance over the same term. The payment drops, but the rate stays the same. Not every servicer or loan type allows it. See recasting vs. refinancing.
PMI cancellation: if PMI is the main reason you want to refinance, you may be able to remove PMI without refinancing.
Home equity loan or line of credit: borrowing against your equity with a second loan keeps your first-mortgage rate unchanged.
How to pay the closing costs
You can pay closing costs at closing, roll some into the loan balance, or accept a higher rate in exchange for lender credits. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that points lower your rate in exchange for paying more at closing. Lender credits lower your closing costs in exchange for a higher rate.
Which choice is cheaper depends on how long you keep the loan. See rolling closing costs into your loan and when refinance points pay off.
How to choose
Write down your goal, your current rate and balance, any PMI, and how long you expect to keep the home.
Check current refinance rates to see whether a refinance is likely to beat your rate.
Request Loan Estimates from at least three lenders for the same loan type, term, and points or credits.
Run each offer through the refinance calculator and compare the break-even point and total cost.
Negotiate with the lender you prefer using the competing offers.
If none of the offers breaks even before you expect to move, keep your current loan for now. You can get alerts when refinancing starts to make sense for your mortgage.